Celebrities
Community
Complications & Care
Exercise
Food
Health Care
Legal
Medications
Monitoring
People are Talking
Pregnancy
Products
Psychology
Research
Weight Loss
About Us
Mini Pharmacy
Diabetes Health magazine
Diabetes Health
Diabetes Health magazine
Diabetes Health Professional
Subscribe Now
See What's Inside…
  • Foot Care for Diabetics

    Richard K. Bernstein, MD, discusses 19 proven ways to take care of your feet and avoid diabetes-related complications

  • Broncos QB Steps into the Pocket with Type 1

    Scott Brown writes about Denver Broncos quarterback Jay Cutler's lice since his recent type 1 diagnosis

  • Diabetes and Eating Disorder Come Together as Diabulimia

    Justine Lorelle Blanchard looks at a chilling development among type 1 teens: skipping insulin shots and purging food as a way to achieve rapid weight loss

  • Teens on Insulin Pumps: Are They Safe?

    Beth Morrow follows up on an article we published in May about teens' problems — occasionally fatal — with insulin pumps

See the entire table of contents here!

Get the Free E-Newsletter
Diabetes Health E-Newsletter

Each week the Diabetes Health E-Newsletter delivers links to the very latest in news, reviews, blogs and videos from Diabetes Health direct to your inbox.

See an example E-Newsletter

As a subscriber you'll get access to the amazing Diabetes Health Digital Advantage™ so you can read the current issue of Diabetes Health magazine online wherever you are!

Email Address:
Area of Interest:
Read Online Now!

Diabetes Health Digital Advantage™, the free, online version of Diabetes Health magazine, virtually identical to the bi-monthly Diabetes Health print magazine, has many additional useful features.

While the pages turn in a similar fashion to a magazine's, direct hot links lead to research articles, products and advertiser sites.

Access to the amazing Diabetes Health Digital Advantage™ is through any web browser, so you can read the current issue of Diabetes Health magazine online wherever you are!

Read Online Now!

Free Subscription to Diabetes Health Professional

The must-have resource for physicians, educators and medical professionals who focus on the treatment of diabetes.

Finally! A fresh take on the “professional” journal. Each bi-monthly issue cuts through the jargon and presents the most important information you need to enhance your practice and assist your patients.

Each bi-monthly issue of Diabetes Health Professional is a self-contained handbook covering products, educational resources and the latest diabetes research, complimented by balanced editorial focused on medical news, drug prescription information, clinical practice recommendations and changing treatment options.

Each quarter we send you the latest, most updated research guides, product guides and educational resource guides available for you and your patients.

Learn More About the Professional Subscription

Latest
Popular
Top Rated
Diabetes Health Reference Charts
Diets Archives
SoLo Bar
Print | Email | Share | Comments (0)

JAMA Study Compares the Big Four in Diets

Linda von Wartburg
26 April 2007
Recommend this Article:

Average Rating:

Constant controversy swirls about which kind of weight-loss diet works best, but there is precious little scientific evidence comparing one diet to another. To provide some real diet data, a recent Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) study pitted the Atkins, Zone, LEARN, and Ornish diets against each other in a year-long head-to-head study.

In these four diets, the amounts of allowed protein, fat, and saturated fat are inversely proportional to the amount of each diets carbohydrate content. Atkins is a very low carb diet, high in protein and fat. The Zone is relatively low carb. The LEARN (Lifestyle, Exercise, Attitudes, Relationships, and Nutrition) diet follows national dietary guidelines and is low in fat and high in carbs. Ornish is the highest carb diet.

The study followed 311 non-diabetic overweight or obese pre-menopausal women for one year, after randomly assigning them to one of the four diet plans. They received weekly instruction for eight weeks and then an additional ten-month follow-up. It was the longest and largest study to compare Atkins to other diets.

Those assigned to the Atkins plan, which allows an abundance of meat, fats, and some vegetables but severely limits carbohydrates, had more weight loss and more favorable outcomes for metabolic effects than women on the other three diets. The amount of weight loss at twelve months relative to baseline was 2% to 5%. Average weight loss was 10.4 pounds for Atkins; 3.5 pounds for the Zone; 5.7 pounds for LEARN; and 4.8 pounds for Ornish.

Lipid levels and blood pressures for the Atkins group were comparable or even better than for the other three groups. Fasting glucose concentrations and fasting insulin were not statistically different among the groups. Concerns about possible bad metabolic effects of the Atkins diet were not substantiated during the year. It was not known whether the benefits shown by the Atkins diet were due to the low carb intake or to the high protein intake.

Of course, if youre thinking of changing your diet, a consultation with your healthcare team is advised. However, the researchers did note that their findings should ease the concerns of doctors whose patients want to lose weight by following a low carb, high protein, high fat diet.

Sources: JAMA, March 2007
Atlanta Journal-Constitution


Recommend this Article:

Average Rating:


You May Also Be Interested In...

Type 1 Pop Star, Nick Jonas Tells His Story

comments 938 comments - 26 Apr 2007

Insulin For Type 2 Diabetes: Who, When, And Why?

comments 146 comments - 29 Nov 2007

Low Carbohydrate Diets: Why You Don't Want the "Experts" to Tell You What to Eat

comments 86 comments - 22 Aug 2007

Jonas Brothers Band Member Reveals He Has Diabetes: Nick Jonas, age 14, hopes his story will inspire other kids with diabetes

comments 84 comments - 13 Mar 2007

Jonas Brothers Update: Diabetes Has Not Slowed Down 15-Year-Old Nick Jonas

comments 81 comments - 2 Apr 2008

Has Anyone Else Reversed Diabetes Complications? If You Have, I Want to Hear From You!

comments 75 comments - 10 Apr 2008

The Loneliness of Diabetes

comments 64 comments - 23 Feb 2008

Updated: Readers Challenge Insulin Manufacturers: Help Us Avoid Near-Fatal Mistakes!

comments 53 comments - 18 Jan 2008

Halle Berry Says She's Worked Her Way Up From Type 1 to Type 2 Diabetes

comments 52 comments - 2 Nov 2007

The "Fat-Free Fallacy:" Is It Obesity's Great Enabler?

comments 52 comments - 21 Feb 2008


Comments...

Add your comments about this article below. You can add comments as a registered user or anonymously. If you choose to post anonymously your comments will be sent to our moderator for approval before they appear on this page. If you choose to post as a registered user your comments will appear instantly.

When voicing your views via the comment feature, please respect the Diabetes Health community by refraining from comments that could be considered offensive to other people. Diabetes Health reserves the right to remove comments when necessary to maintain the cordial voice of the diabetes community.

For your privacy and protection, we ask that you do not include personal details such as address or telephone number in any comments posted.

Don't have your Diabetes Health Username? Register now and add your comments to all our content.

Have Your Say...

Username: Password:
Comment: